No, Your Kid Isn’t Lazy — The Economy Is Just Actually That Bad
Imagine a guy
on the phone, pacing back and forth, his phone pressed against his ear, raising
his voice and trying to stay calm. He looks frustrated, huffing and puffing.
“I’m not wasting money” will come out of his mouth countless times. He looks
more and more annoyed. Inside the house, we all sit in silence, trying to
ignore what’s going on, but we all know we can’t. After he finishes his call,
he walks back in, goes upstairs, and immediately ignores everyone in the house.
Parents
everywhere are in the exact same situation, and it is happening far too often.
Most of the
time, parents don’t want to listen. They call you lazy and irresponsible; they
aren’t looking at the facts themselves. The things they considered right back
when they were younger don’t work now because the economy has changed. People
aren’t trying to fail; just the rules are different now.
The numbers
don’t lie either. According to a 2024 Reuters report on Gen Z finances, “46% of Gen
Z adults still need monetary support from their parents.” They are also not
able to save enough to retire and are nowhere near buying a house. This is also
the same conclusion Pew Research came to: “45% say they are
completely financially independent.” This is happening everywhere. Younger
adults will live at home much longer than their parents.
Harvard’s housing study shows most renters
spend 22.4 million, which means they spend more than 30% of their income on
rent. That’s about half the renters in the country: “half of all US renters
were cost burdened.” Topping the charts for most expensive rent is the state of
California. Escaping the state is not easy, though. California’s rent is the
highest in the nation. Rent eats the average Californian’s paycheck.
This is not
just an economics problem. It is a problem rooted in family, with parents
looking at their adult children who are struggling and seeing some sort of
laziness, rather than considering the situation and circumstances. And in that
dynamic, something ruptures. Let’s go back to the phone call on the deck. What
was his parents’ motivation? “I’m not wasting money.” “I’m not lazy.” “Stop
acting like I’m failing on purpose.” None of those lines, in fact, pertain to
money. They are defending their integrity and character.
Research
evidence backs this up. A 2024 study by Johanna Peetz and colleagues, published
in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,
shows “financial worry was associated with seeing one’s partner as behaving
less respectful, understanding, and supportive.” This shows people who are
worried about money consider their partner’s behaviors as negative and evaluate
them in a more negative way, even though, in reality, the partner’s behaviors
have not changed at all. The anxiety creates an altered perception. Parents
likely form the same distorted perceptions when evaluating their adult
children’s financial behavior.
Financial
psychotherapist Vicky Reynal wrote in her book, Often, money difficulties are the tip of the iceberg,
that family money disputes are never about money. She says, “Often, money
difficulties are the proverbial tip of the iceberg.” They are about shame,
control, and the struggles of the parents that were passed through generations.
The deck fight was not about a credit card statement; it was about the parents’
financial anxiety, as long as they could remember, directed at the closest
target.
I think it is
fair to consider challenges to this viewpoint. One common criticism is that
many young people are financially irresponsible, buying expensive coffee and
food and spending hundreds on concerts. Parents see this and don’t seem to
think it is cruel not to help them financially. They think it is tough love.
They believe their kids will learn from it, not helping them financially, just
as they did.
I think it is
easy to see a point they are trying to make, and it is true, just not
completely true. It is true that many young people don’t understand finances
and spend their money poorly. Many young adults buy expensive, unnecessary
items, like food and drinks. However, the research demonstrates that the latter
factor, or not budgeting for small purchases like buying drinks, is not the
primary factor. Even if you cut out every so-called expense, it still wouldn’t
fix the problem of unaffordable housing, which is the primary concern. Framing
the problem as poor self-control rather than a housing crisis only delays the
real conversation.
First, parents
need to consider what something actually costs before assuming their child is
being lazy. Ask them about rent and groceries. You might be surprised, and if
you are not a parent, don’t be oblivious. Teach your parents about what rent
costs and what you pay, because many of them feel this way. Problems wouldn’t
be as big if parents would stop treating them as personal failures, and when
families think of big problems, the opposite might be true. Back to the scene
on the deck, the pacing, the phone call, and the tense voice. It would have
been better to skip the “you are wasting money” accusation and start a
conversation about what is really happening. It’s not going to solve the
problem with the economy or rent, but at least it’s a step toward restoring the
family.
Comments
Post a Comment